What is A MagSafe System?

 A MagSafe system refers to a collection of accessories designed to work in harmony with Apple's MagSafe technology. Brands with MagSafe systems, include Apple, Peak Design, Bellroy and more. Some brands' accessories lock you into just using their products, because they have features that don't translate outside their system. Others brands accessories are able to mix and match with third party products. There's a wide range in user experience. When shopping for MagSafe cases or accessories, it's important to consider whether you'll be locked into a system or whether you prefer having more flexibility.

So, what should you do? Go all in on a MagSafe system that offers you more flexibility or try an innovative product that might lock you into using just one brand? In this post, we'll explore the pros and cons of each system, so you can make the best choice for you.

What is a Locked MagSafe System?

One of the primary differentiators between a locked system and a flexible system is whether there is a barrier to using the MagSafe accessories with other third party products. What exactly does that mean? To dive deeper into that, let's consider Bellroy's Mod Phone Case + Wallet as good example.

While the Bellroy Mod Phone Case is compatible with other third party MagSafe accessories, their magnetic wallet only works with their Mod Phone Case. The Bellroy magnetic wallet has a "Modrail" feature that sticks out of the bottom, and fits into the groove on the Mod Phone Case. If you ever wanted to switch to a different brand for your iPhone case, your Bellroy magnetic wallet would no longer be compatible. In this way, you are "locked" into using their magnetic wallet only with their case.

Pros and Cons of A Locked System

Pros

1. Reliability and Compatibility: The MagSafe accessories have been designed to work flawlessly with the rest of the brand's system. Users can trust that everything will align perfectly and function optimally.

2. Quality: Many of these branded systems prioritize high-end materials and build quality, which ensures longevity and a premium feel.

3. Streamlined Experience: The brand's accessories like wallets and chargers are designed to integrate seamlessly with these proprietary systems, making for a clean, easy-to-use experience.

Cons

1. Limited Flexibility: Once you’re committed to a particular brand’s "locked" system, it can be hard to switch. Other brands may offer better features, more innovative designs, or better prices, but won’t integrate as seamlessly (or at all) with your existing accessories.

2. Cost: Because the third party system is proprietary, it often doesn't have to compete with other "knock-offs" or open systems. Due to this, they can charge more, because there isn't competition.

What is a Flexible MagSafe System?

A flexible MagSafe system offers users the opportunity to mix and match their accessories with other third party products. Apple's has a very flexible system, and it should! Their goal is to reach the largest number of customers using the iPhone product. Their accessories work with their MagSafe cases, many third party cases, and on any bare iPhone from 12 to 16.

Pros and Cons of A Flexible System

Pros

1. Variety: More flexible brand systems, like Apple, have more options that are compatible across more third party companies. This allows users to mix and match accessories based on needs or budget.

2. Innovation: Companies outside of locked and proprietary MagSafe systems often introduce new, creative designs and features that might not be available in the closed system. In part, this is because they have a larger audience to cater to than just the few that have elected to be in a more locked-in system.

3. Cost: Systems that are more flexible usually have more competition in the market. This results in a variety of price points varying from very expensive to down right bargain.

Cons

1. Potential Compatibility Issues: When you mix and match brands, you may find that some accessories work better with your chosen case and vice versa. Sometimes, you may run into issues with misalignment or functionality.

2. Inconsistent Quality: If you are using products from a variety of brands, you may not always get the same level of build quality or durability across each product.

To Sum Up: It Comes Down to You

When it comes to MagSafe systems, the decision ultimately depends on how much you’re willing to spend, how often you upgrade your devices, and how much flexibility you want and/or need. If you're heavily invested in a proprietary system and prefer that experience, sticking with that brand's MagSafe system might be worth the cost. But if you're looking for more variety, potentially more affordability, or unique features, a more flexible MagSafe system might be a better option for you.

Author's Note: The photo above is of the OpenCase MagSafe System, which is mostly flexible.  All the MagSafe accessories work with any bare iPhone 12-16 and most third party MagSafe cases; however, only third party MagSafe accessories that fit in the "open" space are compatible, like the Apple wallet and more.